Going the extra mile to serve her customers is just part of business for Amy Luetke. Amy prides herself with exceeding her customer’s expectations in real estate service by taking every step necessary to facilitate a seamless and hassle free transaction.
Amy believes buying and selling homes should be an exciting and satisfying experience for all parties involved. Extraordinary service, knowledge of the market and the caring relationships she has with her customers create positive real estate experiences.
Continuing education is very important to Amy as different aspects of the real estate business are constantly changing. She currently holds 5 specialized designations and takes new classes every year to keep her on the cutting edge of the real estate business. Amy has also been honored by the National Association of Realtors, the Glenwood Springs Association of Realtors, the Glenwood Springs Chamber Resort Association and the Post Independent as a Local’s Choice Gold Winner.
Amy is not only passionate about real estate, she also enjoys the outdoors, her family and friends, traveling and decorating. She is happily settled in New Castle with her three children.
Certifications & Awards
- CRS (Certified Residential Specialist)
- GRI (Graduate Realtor Institute)
- CNE (Certified Negotiation Expert)
- SFR (Short Sale, Foreclosure Resource)
- CDPE (Certified Distressed Property Expert)
- Post Independent Local’s Choice Gold Winner
- River Center, Board of Directors
- Elk Creek Elementary PTAC
- Riverside Middle School RAP
- Coal Ridge High School Booster Club
- Extended Table Volunteer
- Member of Good Shepherd Lutheran Church
Outstanding service. Whether buying or selling, always consistent. Never is anything left undone. Very professional and on top of her game. Love working with her and being assured of a job seen through to completion without incident. Highly recommend Amy and her devotion to her clients. You can be assured of her attention to detail and knowing everything will be done on time and in a professional manner. Thanks Amy, we so appreciate the great job you always do.
– Jan Huck (TPS Website Review – September 2021)
Now that the dust has settled, I want to thank Amy and Erin for the seamless sale of our Oak Meadows townhome! We had 5 great offers within days and we could not have moved forward, literally or figuratively without this team!! We were WAAAYYYY too busy with our “stuff’. Kudos to Laura for giving us the keys to the truck more times than we can believe…as well as Tracey for her staging suggestions. Great photos capped off the winning choice in realtors. IF we ever move back to the RFV, you will be our first call!! See u soon-ish!! xo
– Amy Levenson (Facebook Review – July 2021)
Amy is the best! Her attention to detail on both the selling and buying aspect is phenomenal! She’s efficient and makes the process so easy from start to finish! Thanks Amy! I appreciate you!
– Jerri Cox (TPS Website Review – July 2021)
Wow! Amy is still the best. She has reached out to me on a few different occasions to let me know the value of our property. This time the timing was right. The photos, the props, etc made this easy to sell. Love when you get more than the asking price!
– John Lee (TPS Website Review – June 2021)
Amy was a pleasure to work with throughout the sale of our family property. She was professional, maintained ongoing contact with me throughout the process, and managed to bring a personal touch to the entire process. She gave sage advice and helped me navigate the sale of a complex property. She started as my Realtor, but I now consider her a friend. You can’t go wrong with Amy, nor The Property Shop. She has my highest endorsement!
– Jo Anne Licht (TPS Website Review – March 2021)
I had the pleasure of working with Amy. Not only did she hear out concerns and advocated for us more than a dozen times. She understood us and was the voice that we did not have. She was able to find us an amazing home, and with us being first time homebuyers she was so patient answering all of our questions and making sure we had a good deal. Her team was so nice in lending us their truck, always so welcoming. Would highly recommend.
– Miriam Vigil (TPS Website Review – January 2021)
Amy was referred to us by two previous clients. From the very beginning Amy addressed every issue or question we had. We are not cyber fluent, but she made it all very simple for us. There was some unusual turbulence through our experience and Amy handled it with calm professionalism. I have always thought realtor fees were somewhat unreasonably high, but through our dealing with Amy I can see that there is a lot more to their service than simply listing a property and taking a nice fat check at the end. A real estate client is receiving year long and life long personal investment in a realtors knowledge, experience, and skills which enable them to accomplish what we need but are not able to do for ourselves. THANK YOU TPS AND AMY
– James Pezoldt (TPW Website Review – December 2020)
Amy was great! I highly recommend.
– Tony Salais (TPS Website Review – November 2020)
Amy was great to work with. Very thorough and took care of everything and responded in a timely manner. We got exactly what we needed out of the sale of our house and she took care of all the details. I wish we had her as our Realtor for the house we bought as well!
– Kimberly Young (TPS Website Review – November 2020)
When we started looking for houses, my husband found the Realtor online with the best reviews and Amy did not disappoint! She made our search 100x better than we could have hoped. We were looking in the fall with a little less inventory and some specific wants. Amy and Erin got us in to see everything we wanted ASAP. They were knowledgeable about the properties and honest about expectations. Once we zoned in they took great care during every step to make sure we, and everyone else, were on schedule and in the loop. They always had our best interest at the forefront of their recommendations and gave great direction. This was our first home together and a big milestone for our family. We are so grateful to have Amy guide us through the process and help place our family in a great spot! Thanks so much Amy and Erin!
– Taylor Narreau (Facebook Review – October 2020)
Once again, Amy went above and beyond to make sure that our transaction went smoothly. Her attention to detail, and readiness, really streamline the process from start to finish. Thanks again Amy.
– Alex Janckila (TPS Website Review – October 2020)
Amy did amazing work for us. She was well organized, very personable, and easy to work with. She went out of her way to help us find the right home in the right place at the right time. I highly recommend Amy Luetke and the entire team at The Property Shop!
– Shay Smith (TPS Website Review – August 2020)
We found Amy to be a pleasure to work with! She is a great communicator. Very knowledgeable and extremely helpful with details and contacts. This made the process of selling and closing efficient and smooth. Much appreciated! Thank you Amy!
– Nancee Goodrich (TPS Website Review – August 2020)
The experience of selling our home went very well. Amy asked us questions, she came out to our home, and guided us through preparing our home for sale. When it came time to put the house for sale she would let us know ahead of time what to expect, making sure we understood details and signing of papers. We were glad to have her as our Realtor.
– Arnold & Beth Vander Meer (TPS Website Review – August 2020)
Another incredible home sale with Amy and the crew. This was our second home in selling with Amy and The Property Shop. They are AMAZING. Amy and Erin had great communication. The whole team is wonderful and really pull it all together. Our first sale was fast, but this one was under contract within a few weeks and closed within two months of listing. They have such a dynamic way of making you feel like friends, but they always stay professional and straight forward honest. Thanks Amy. These are the experiences that home sellers/buyers are suppose to have with no hassle.
– Michael and Karen Zimmerman (TPS Website Review – August 2020)
Awesome from start to finish. Amy is second to none!!!
– Randy Whitley (TPS Website Review – August 2020)
The Property Shop is the best in town. They are knowledgeable, thoughtful, and a pleasure to work with. Highly recommend!
– Nicole Capehart (TPS Website Review – July 2020)
Where do I begin? Had it not been for Amy, at The Property Shop, I’m not sure, at my age, I would have survived the whole experience of selling and buying a house. Amy guided us through everything and we always knew she had our back and would take care of every little bump in the road. I 100% recommend Amy and The Property Shop.
– Jeannie Cox (Facebook Review – July 2020)
I met with Amy she worked up a property comparison. She didn’t pressure me she told me she was there if and when I decided to sell. I did this right as the COVID19 was active in our state and county. She took precautions and safety was her goal. She secured a buyer for me and in a short time I was under contract and ready for the sell. She gave wonderful insight and knowledge in the process. I feel she represented me and I was in good hands all the way through closing. I appreciate everything thing she did for me. I can see why she was highly recommended. Thank you Amy!!!
– Lorrie Raffensperger (TPW Website Review – May 2020)
It’s always a pleasure to work with Amy. She kept us well informed throughout the entire process and quickly resolved any issues to keep things running smoothly. Thanks Amy!
– Trevor R (TPS Website Review – April 2020)
Amy and Erin helped us thread a needle in the midst of the Covid19 scare, working all hours of the day. We sold and bought a house despite all the challenges. We were able to use The Property Shop’s moving truck several times, allowing us to move small loads over a period when movers were scarce. Amy was able to navigate the uncharted waters of the Covid19 regulations and sell our house and deliver us our dream home. Everything they promised, they delivered above and beyond! This team is the best around without a doubt! Thank you Amy, Erin, and The Property Shop!
– Chris Clarke (Facebook Review – April 2020)
Amy is simply the best. She is so pleasant to work with – fun, reassuring, knowledgeable. Her team that helped stage and photograph the house was amazing as well! Amy was always very responsible and if she didn’t have the answer to something she’d find out and get back to us ASAP. She was very communicative (but not overly so) and gave helpful, timely insights and directives. We unexpectedly found ourselves selling and buying a house during the COVID-19 crisis, which brought a whole new set of challenges. I was so grateful to have Amy helping to drive things forward and calm my anxieties! I highly recommend Amy on both the buying and selling side of the equation.
– Lindy Clarke (Facebook Review – April 2020)
It was a pleasure working with Amy. I always got answers when needed. Answers or solutions were resolved in a very timely matter. Thanks again Amy!
– Tim Wittenberg (TPS Website Review – December 2019)
Amy and her team worked together and with us to prepare our home for showings. It presented well and photographed wonderfully. Questions were answered quickly and it was comfortable asking “rookie” questions. Amy was very accessible and it was a fairly easy process. Thanks Amy!!
– Julie Fite (TPS Website Review – October 2019)
We were referred to Amy at TPS when we decided to move to Glenwood Springs from the Denver area. Amy not only was extremely professional, prompt, and responsive to all our questions, concerns and needs, she treated us like new neighbors. The Property Shop treats its customers like family as they work to meet the real estate needs in a very tight-knit community. Working with any other company would be a disservice to you and your move.
– Alexandra Braeger (TPS Website Review – August 2019)
Amy is fantastic! When we moved to the area clueless about the different towns/neighborhoods she took her time to show us around everywhere to make sure we had a good sense of the area! It was so helpful and she was so patient even with our children! Then we just sold our home and she made it happen in a timely fashion and was in contact with every situation that came up. We felt like we were in excellent and capable hands. Thank you Amy! We definitely recommend Amy and The Property Shop!
– Alex Woolley (TPS Website Review – July 2019)
Everyone at The Property Shop were amazing. We would highly recommend Amy.
– Michael & Karen Zimmerman (TPS Website Review – June 2019)
Without Amy, I would not be in my new home. She went about and beyond in making my deal go through; never giving up on the idea that there was a solution. She kept me posted about everything that was happening throughout the process and supported me emotionally through the ups and downs.
– Cathy Kirkpatrick (TPS Website Review – June 2019)
I purchased my new townhome in New Castle in 2007 thru Amy Luetke at The Property Shop. It worked perfectly. It was a positive experience then and we have remained friends. Now, several years later, Amy sold it for me. Again, a perfectly positive experience. She and Erin Greenwald helped me both times, are a pleasure to work with and are extremely professional. Their client base and abilities resulted in a quick sale and closing with ease and no stress. I signed the agency contract and they literally did the rest. I thank them again and look forward to doing more business with them and The Property Shop in the future.
– John Collins (TPS Website Review – June 2019)
Amy was very detailed oriented from start to finish on the sale of my home. She guided me through all the steps and negotiations of the transaction. I relied on her expertise and experience. I very much appreciated her in the transaction and her friendship developed along the way.
– Linda Fender (TPS Website Review – June 2019)
Amy Luetke and the staff at The Property Shop are AMAZING! A good friend recommended her and we found out why. She managed the sale of my elderly mother’s home of many years with kindness for her and great efficiency for family being across the country. We were well informed every step of the way and questions welcomed. My husband even commented “that was a smooth sale and transition”, and we have more than a few home sells under our belt. We felt we received a good price and it sold in a short time. She knows her market. Thank you Amy and The Property Shop!
– Rhonda Zoller (Facebook Review – April 2019)
Amy was responsive and helpful in my experience as a first time home buyer. She was pleasant, prompt and realistic in our communications.
– K K (TPS Website Review – November 2018)
We have used Amy for buying and selling several properties. She is always on top of it all! She is fabulous! She knows her stuff! Thanks Amy, your amazing!
– Darla Grangroth (TPS Website Review – November 2018)
Amy is very professional and is obviously very experienced in real estate! She kept us up to date, answered all our questions promptly and made the whole transaction go smoothly. We will highly recommend her to anyone buying or selling real estate. Thank you Amy, we appreciate your service!
– Art Harju (TPS Website Review – November 2018)
There are not enough words to describe the professionalism that Amy and EVERYONE in her office brings to the closing table! From start to finish our selling process was so smooth and easy! Will use Amy and The Property Shop Inc. for our next selling/purchasing endeavor. Our home sold in 3 days full price offer! Professional photos to staging she is the best!
– BB (Zillow Review – November 2018)
We hired Amy to sell our Carbondale home of 16 years. We requested that there be an open line of communication good or bad. Amy was excellent in all areas but especially in keeping us informed about possible buyers. We would highly recommend Amy as your agent as she works hard on your behalf and makes the selling process manageable. The Property Shop is the right company to use for the sale of your property.
– Brad Nicholson (TPS Website Review – November 2018)
As a seller I very much appreciated the advice regarding getting the property inside and out ready to sell. Amy’s market knowledge was strategic and critical as we positioned the house in the local market. Her negotiating expertise was indispensable and very effective. The knowledge of technical real estate issues helped us respond appropriately as a number of issues stood as potential deal killers but were avoided and resolved proactively. Top rated selling experience for me and hence the strong recommendation!
– Scott Norvell (TPS Website Review – October 2018)
Amazing! Knows the area and market well. Very helpful in finding a home we love! She was able to assist us through closing on selling to someone we knew, as well as purchase a property before it even had a chance to hit the market!
– Brent Herrala (Zillow Review – October 2018)
Cannot state strongly enough how much I enjoyed working with Amy. She volunteered to help with matters I would have never expected or thought of involving my real estate agent. I needed a painter for my new house – she found one. I needed a contractor for some projects – she found one. At every turn, Amy was there to help. She knows the market, she’s well regarded by her fellow professionals, she is reasonable in negotiations. I have had the good fortune to work with some very good realtors, but I have to say Amy ranks among the top of the list. My only regret about closing my real estate deals is I won’t have the occasions to visit Amy, who I now consider not just a real estate agent, but a good friend.
– Kevin G. (Zillow Review – October 2018)
I have worked with Amy on the sale of two different properties. Amy is a well- experienced professional with excellent judgment and great people skills. In my opinion, a sale is most successful when the seller and broker forge a partnership and bring their strengths to the table. I felt I was welcomed onto Amy’s team, including her wonderful assistant Erin, and we all worked together well. No undue pressure or unrealistic expectations, just the diligent and systematic pursuit of success. I highly recommend Amy and her team.
– Barbara K. (TPS Website Review – August 2018)
I have many words all accompanied with red hearts and explanation marks!!! The Amy and Erin duo are a forced to be reckoned with! Between the two of them in a very short time knew who best to handle my ability to flip out at a moments notice! I recently called Amy crying over the final day of the sale of my home in Downtown NC because I was tired, stressed and over the moon with worry, she knew exactly what to say! I can’t believe how the 3 of us interacted with each other it’s as if they both knew what I needed, which is strange as my house got an offer on the day I listed it with Amy at the awesome PS!! Amy handled everything; she talked me through everything that I needed clarity on! I consider Any and Erin my new friends and I’m looking forward to many excursions at Eat Drink Bistro with these two! Highest praises lifted up to y’all! I will miss working with them and I thank them from the bottom of my Thank you to all y’all for giving me the use of your amazing van! Good job a ton of to all!
– Candy Norvell (TPS Website Review – July 2018)
Amy did a great job getting us through a challenging negotiation and getting our property sold. Amy is a real professional and I would highly recommend her for any real estate transaction in the area.
– David Overly (TPS Website Review – June 2018)
Working with Amy was a delight! She made this complicated and stressful process simple and exciting. Her professionalism is exceeded only by her personal touch that makes it feel like you are her only client. Cannot say enough good about Amy and The Property Shop! Oh, and free use of The Property Shop moving truck? Yes please!! AMY IS AMAZING!
– Josh Hejtmanek (Zillow Review – May 2018)
We have used Amy many times over the past 10 years. She is beyond great to work with. She makes buying and selling homes so easy! She works hard and does a great job! I Highly recommend her!
– Annye Kumpula (TPS Website Review – April 2018)
Amy Luetke was exceptional through the entire process. We needed to sell our home quickly with an unexpected move. She was in contact with us throughout the entire process and helped us know what to do for our property as well as what to expect throughout the process from pre-listing to closing. Rarely, do you find such a glowing, exceptional experience from beginning to end. We are so grateful for all her help, would recommend her to anyone who needs a true professional, and wish her and her team all the best! Thank you, Amy!!
– Bruce Densley (, Facebook Review – March 2018)
Amy Luetke is the most awesome realtor around Garfield county. She works all out for you and keeps well informed on whats going on with the sale of your house or the buying of your house. She is so very helpful with many great points on how to make your home more saleable. The first customer that looked at my house bought it and gave me exactly what I wanted. The sale went very smooth and with out complications. I highly recommend Amy as your realtor she won’t let you down, you won’t be sorry! Call Amy from the Property Shop she’s your realtor!
– Adria Milton-Baker (Facebook Review – January 2018)
Amy was amazing to work with! She is extremely professional, knowledgeable, and truly cares about her clients. The whole process, from selling to buying and moving, is very stressful, but Amy made it happen quickly and painlessly! Thank you!
– Jocelyn Kochevar ( Facebook Review – November 2017)
The Property Shop is the best! Amy Luetke is an outstanding realtor. She truly goes above and beyond to make the home buying/selling process as easy as possible. She is detailed, knowledgeable and professional. I would highly recommend her if you are looking to buy or sell your home.
– Mary Chavez ( Facebook Review – September 2017)
We found Amy Luetke by chance and are so glad that we did. She spent several months (yes months…) with us looking for a new home. She was professional, knowledgeable, understanding of our needs, and she truly cared about our family. I truly cannot say enough good things about Amy. If you are looking for a realtor, stop. Just pick Amy.
PS – Her assistant Erin is absolutely fabulous too!
– Kelly Stueven (TPS Website Review – September 2017)
Amy was great, kept us informed through the whole process and we sold our town home in less then 30 days! Thanks Amy
– Dave Malehorn (TPS Website Review – September 2017)
Amy Luetke had been our realtor for 2 home purchases over the past 3 years. She is very knowledgeable and a true professional. Both sales went thru without a hitch and the properties were delivered to us in excellent condition. The Property Shop provides so many thoughtful items to make your move go smoothly – including the use of a 15′ rental truck! We will always choose The Property Shop for any future real estate needs.
– Emily Resnick McCarty (, Facebook Review – July 2017)
We had a great experience in working with Amy. She is very dedicated to ensuring that all of our needs are met, and kept us informed of updates throughout the entire process. We are so pleased to have had her as our realtor and look forward to working with her for future real estate opportunities.
– Ann Byman (TPS Website Review – May 2017)
It was a pleasure to work with Amy on a professional level as well as knowing her personally over the years. She knows the market extremely well and responded immediately to any concern or question we had. TPS has a valued reputation in the Valley due to it’s wonderful staff and commitment to clients. Thank you Amy, we will miss you!!
– David Drake (TPS Website Review – May 2017)
Amy was a pleasure to work with for the sale of one of our transferees. Always prompt, courteous and informed. I look forward to working with her again in the future.
– Donna Woods (TPS Website Review – April 2017)
Amy did a great job with the sale of our townhome. Our sale was as smooth as it could ever be. She gave us great advice and we felt confident in our transaction. Everyone we dealt with at TPS was very kind and helpful. A great team of professionals. We were very happy with our experience. Thank you
– Andrea Grangroth (TPS Website Review – April 2017)
Amy is great to work with! She did everything possible to make the process easy for me.
– Trevor R. (TPS Website Review – April 2017)
Amy does a great job, goes over and above to make sure you have all you need! Would definitely use her again!
– Amy Waaraniemi (TPS Website Review – April 2017)
Amy is the Best Realtor in the valley!!
– Austin Farley (TPS Website Review – March 2017)
Amy is not only professional, she’s personable. She has a good feel for the market – what’s available & what the values are. She’s a local with many connections. We’ve listed, sold & bought past properties with her & will do it again. We’d highly recommend her to anyone looking for a hard-working, honest & professional agent in the area.
– L & J Henderson (TPS Review – February 2017)
Contact Amy Luetke
Amy Luetke has been a licensed real estate agent for 18 years and is currently a Broker/Owner with The Property Shop, Inc. Amy focuses on residential real estate in Glenwood Springs, Carbondale, Rifle, Silt, New Castle, and Parachute, Colorado.